Tuesday, March 24, 2020

Language Blog Post

Despite the constant regulations and lockdowns being set into action these past couple weeks, my family and I have had no difficulties keeping ourselves entertained, whether its with puzzles, binge-watching new Netflix series, or just plain-old conversation within the comfort of our own living room.  I have noticed that whatever activity is at hand, regardless of what it is, communication is the main component that instigates and adds fluidity to our activities.  When we were assigned to partake in a conversation without any version of a symbolic language, the activities that were at hand became a lot less fluid and a little more robotic.  I decided to try this experiment with my two younger siblings, who both obviously lead the conversation seeing as to the fact I could not physically speak.  My contributions to the conversation were limited strictly to responses, such as nodding my head up or down to give a simple "yes" or "no".  I cursed myself for never taking sign language in high school, which made this experiment difficult and overall lead to nowhere in terms of my communication.  However, my siblings failed to show any signs of indifference toward me, and actually spoke more freely and asked more questions as a result from my silence.  Although they did their best to include me in most conversations, there were times in which I had no choice but to only observe and listen, such as an eruption of a side topic or a joke being told, which  i could respond to only with a laugh.  Nonetheless, there was no doubt about who owned the conversations held throughout the experiment, it was clearly my siblings were were laughing hysterically by the end of the night.  To analyze this experiment in a parallel format, the similarities can be made between two cultures who have different methods of communication.  Although I had a minimal amount of success using a communicative method that uses no symbolic language, there may be cultures that exist today that may be able to use this method very effectively.  However, the results from the experiment shows that the culture with a spoken language may have an easier time communicating complex ideas within their population because our alphabet and speech allows it.  Because of this, it may seem as though the culture with a spoken language share more intelligence amongst themselves than the culture without a spoken language, and this belief may be exhibited through their behavior towards one another.  One example of this that can be seen in recent history is the colonization of our miraculous country, which was stolen from Natives that did not speak in the same tongue as the Europeans who colonized their land.  The Europeans believed they were more intelligent than the Natives because of their lack of knowledge in terms of language, and so they took advantage of them.

The second part of this assignment was evidently more difficult than it lead on to be.  Absence of any physical movement, along with lack of vocal intonations and arm movements made communicating a point more difficult.  My partners, who have switched from my siblings to now both of my parents, were constantly being thrown off by my points being made in my conversation because the lack of emotion and enthusiasm in the way I was communicating was sending mixed signals.  We take for granted our ability to use signs as a form of communication, because without them it is hard to tell what exactly is trying to be communicated in the first place.  This is shown to be true because a lot of information can be found out just by paying attention to someone's body language, such as the kind of mood they're in, what their immediate intentions may be, or even what they may be thinking.  Reading someone's body language is also a major tool when it comes to survival because it could mean the difference between life or death.  When in the wild, and being constantly on the lookout for other predators, it is essential to be able to recognize the dangers posed in front of you and react.  Reading the body language of a predator can give off signals of a potential threat, which can be recognized and escaped from if noticed early enough.  Avoiding predators makes more time to gather resources, which increase a likelihood of reproducing.  An exemplary situation that reading body language is not useful in is when put in front of a pathological liar, who may appear as sincere when telling a lie.  A common method to distinguish liars is to look at their eyes, and see if they lock onto yours or not.  But this can become deceitful once a pathological liar does the same thing.  It goes to show that body language is not always reliable, and as a matter of fact can be used as a tool to deceit others.

4 comments:

  1. Hello,

    I enjoyed reading how your experiment went. I liked how you used younger siblings at first and then changed in the second experiment to your parents. I thought about doing that but I wanted to know what my subjects thought of the second one compared to the first one. If you had to do this again, what do you think about switching the positions of your younger siblings and your parents. It'll be interesting to see how younger siblings react to there be words but no emotion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Envision, I have no idea who you are. Your username (when I click on it) has no blog associated with it, so I can't assign credit for your comments. When you post comments, make sure you are logged into the blog you use for this class so that your correct username pops up.

      Email me to identify who you are and I can update your grade book.

      Delete
  2. Initial comment: When all your points are collapsed into one paragraph, it makes it difficult to parse out your responses to each prompt. It is to your advantage to ensure that your answers are clearly indicated. Separate each set of guideline prompts into separate paragraphs.

    Part 1: Good opening description, but understand that knowing ASL wouldn't have helped as that is ALSO a form of symbolic language. Understand the difference between "sign language" (symbolic) and using "signs" (i.e., NOT symbolic) for communication.

    A little short in the discussion on power and control in the conversation. This was an important issue that needed to be explored further.

    I agree with your conclusion regarding which culture has the advantage.

    That is really interesting example. I do want to suggest that this was more complex than language. Back up and think about who had the advantage when the first Pilgrims came over. It wasn't the Pilgrims. They nearly starved and died that first winter. I suggest that the reason the Native Americans had a disadvantage later was due to (a) the sheer volume of Europeans was greater, (b) the Europeans had guns and other more powerful weapons and (c) Europeans brought disease with them that contributed to the deaths of a significant proportion of the Native American populations. But your suggestion isn't far off. We see this in the interaction between English speakers and non-English speaking immigrant populations. Think about how non-English speaking immigrants are treated in Southern California? Are they treated as equals?

    Part 2: Okay on your description here, but usually the most interesting part of this experiment is the response of the partner. Some have actually gotten angry and stormed out. It would have offered more information for both you and your reader if this had been expanded.

    I don't disagree with your conclusions regarding the information we receive from body language, but you are only considering the situation where body language matches and supports the information you receive from spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce (which applies to the next section).

    Okay on the benefits of body language, but this goes far beyond detecting predation. And what type of benefits do you get by being able to detect liars?

    Missing an identification of those who have difficulty reading body language? There are groups of people who have great difficulty or an outright inability to read body language due to physical or mental disability, such as those who are in the autism spectrum or those who are blind (though they can read vocal intonation).

    Being a pathological liar doesn't mean they don't have 'tells' with their body language to indicate that they are lying. In fact, body language may be the only way you could detect his lies. Would you really want to give up that one option for not falling prey to his deception?

    But is there any situation you can think of where body language might actually mislead you, not because the person is lying but because you don't know how to read the body language? Do all cultures use the same system of body language? They all use different systems of spoken/written language, so why would we assume their body language isn't different? If you travel to another country, can you trust the information you get from their body language?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Angelo,
    I think it is interesting how different your conversations went. I think by using two different age groups you gave us more insight on how age can affect the way people respond to us. I think this proves that kids do not care if you are responding verbally as long as you are listening. I think they loved having control of the conversation. When it came to the second part of the assignment I think we all had the same response by our partners. The lack of emotion can lead to mixed signals and also lead to a very uncomfortable conversation. I think this assignment just goes to show how much we rely on both spoken language and body language. Great job on the post!

    ReplyDelete